Share from 0:00
0:00
/

He stopped paying for his own name, and performance went up

Ajit Sivadasan, ex-Lenovo, on why marketing can’t prove what works, and why AI won’t fix it for you

Ajit Sivadasan once noticed something odd in Lenovo’s numbers. Media prices were rising by 3–4% a year, but Lenovo’s advertising costs were rising by 15–20%. He spent 19 years at Lenovo building its global online business from 5 countries to more than 35, so he knew the numbers well enough to spot a gap like that. When he went looking for where the money was going, he found that branded search was eating 30–40% of the budget.

That means Lenovo was paying Google to show Lenovo’s name to people who were already typing “Lenovo”. As he put it, it’s like Apple paying for its own name to tell customers they should buy from Apple.

The platforms said branded search was the best-performing line on the plan. Of course it was: people searching for your name are about to buy anyway. Ajit cut it by almost 40% and moved the money into non-brand search, which reaches people who haven’t decided yet. Performance went up.

This was our first remote recording, and Ajit’s subject was why marketing can no longer prove what works, and whether AI fixes that or makes it worse. Claude asked the questions, and Claude didn’t go easy on him.

“Were you part of the problem?”

The moment I’d point you to is when Claude asked Ajit whether his years of very large digital budgets had helped build the opaque platforms he now criticises. He didn’t dodge it. “Obviously,” he said. The business was growing and the data looked good, “so you kind of swept everything under the carpet.” He only started digging when he stepped in as acting CMO and the costs stopped making sense.

That fits with something I’ve heard several times on this show: big organisations rarely change until they’re under real pressure. Lenovo was doing well enough that nobody had a reason to question the platforms.

Dashboards as shackles

Claude asked what Peter Drucker, who taught Ajit at Claremont, would make of a modern marketing dashboard. Ajit thought he’d be confused, because Drucker’s two questions were always: who is your customer, and what does your customer consider value? A dashboard answers neither.

I told the dashboard story from SmartAssets. Clients would always ask us, “Where’s the dashboard?”, even when the honest answer to “which asset worked best?” was “it’s really hard to tell.” Ajit took it further than I would have: “They become the shackles. They become the reason why you’re not thinking.” Once you measure something, he said, the whole organisation reorganises itself around the flaws in that measure.

So can AI fix it?

Ajit doesn’t think so, at least not on its own. “AI is not going to tell you what the thesis is.” If you give AI flawed data and a flawed reference point, it gives you a flawed answer, just faster. The platforms’ new AI tools that plan, buy and measure campaigns still only see their own platform. Claude called that “the same opacity, just automated”, and Ajit agreed.

What fixed the problem at Lenovo was a thesis. Ajit believed they were too transactional and weren’t telling the product story, so every launch ended up discounted. Then he tested that belief. The data showed him there was a problem. It took his own judgement, and some courage, to work out what the problem was.

“AI is not going to tell you what the thesis is”Thanks for reading I, Claude & Us! This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share

The question Claude should have asked

The show always ends with “What question should I have asked you?” Ajit’s answer was this: ask how he uses Claude for all of his work, because he hasn’t hired a single person and he’s ready to launch a company.

So after I turned Claude off, I asked him. He uses it for everything, from NDAs and service agreements to website requirements, QA and pitch decks. He started by writing a book that set out the thesis for the business, working 10 hours a day for three months. He calls Claude “a sparring partner that is intellectually at a higher level that allows you to raise your own game.”

He also gave a warning, and Claude was listening. If you don’t have a clear plan, “Claude will spin you up.” It can reinforce half-truths and lead you off track. His answer is what he calls a strategic spine. He decides the chapters before he writes a word, so he stays the one in charge. “You are the master and you are the one who’s driving the vision, not the other way around.”

That’s very close to what Diane Bradley called the “human container” in our previous episode. AI gets more useful when a human puts structure around it.

Listen to the full episode above, or on YouTube. If you’ve ever switched off a line on your media plan that the platform swore was working, I’d love to hear what happened. Leave a comment.

Chapters

0:00 Introducing Ajit Sivadasan

1:22 When did the numbers stop telling the truth?

3:57 Paying for customers who'd buy anyway

8:15 Switching off branded search

9:12 Courage and having a thesis

14:18 Gut versus data

16:12 Peter Drucker and the dashboard

17:06 Dashboards become shackles

19:32 Can AI fix it?

22:03 Were you part of the problem?

24:16 Are CMOs paid to look confident?

27:01 Why trust SMBXChange?

29:44 What question should I have asked you?

30:01 Building a company with Claude

34:24 Wrap-up

I, Claude & Us is an independent podcast. It isn’t affiliated with or sponsored by Anthropic.

Ten questions. No prep. AI asks.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?